|


In Miracle Fair, Nobel Laureate poet Wislawa
Szymborska celebrates the everyday wonders of our seemingly uneventful lives.
Oral history reflects this spirit of commonplace miracles. It attempts to
capture the lives of persons who most often have gone unnoticed and celebrates
seemingly-insignificant experiences. If we bother to look closely and with
imagination, we will understand what Leo Tolstoy meant when he said that the
life of an ordinary person could be the most complex piece of literature if it
were captured properly.
 |
Phil Donovan never depended on
technology for his fishery. "I know every mark now just the same as I did 60 or
70 years ago." |
Oral history offers literacy educators and their students
opportunities to explore, capture, and celebrate their lives and those of
others in their communities. It provides a way for unheard or silenced voices
to be heard. Moreover, oral history equips us educators with a viable
methodology we can use to help our students become more proficient readers and
writers.
Recording and Being
Recorded Community-based literacy programs throughout Canada and
the United States have often made effective use of oral history. We can find
collections of life stories told by people from different backgrounds and
various contexts. Whether hunting tales told by Native elders in Nunavut or sea
stories told by the fishers of Newfoundland, these oral history texts provide
us with valuable resources to use with our students. Likewise, they serve as
models which we can emulate in our own programs.
Quite often these oral history collections have been recorded
and written by literacy instructors or others involved in literacy work. That
is, they have captured their students life experiences by using some
variation of the Language Experience Approach (LEA) in which the student
dictates a story while the instructor writes it. LEA is a fine instructional
methodology with a decades-long record of effectiveness. We recommend its
continued use where appropriate.
What we want to advocate and briefly describe is how to utilize
oral history in the literacy program by having adult students actually do the
recording. By providing students with the appropriate structure, support, and
practical skills, we can help them become the interviewers, recorders, and oral
historians of their own communities. This will greatly enhance their literacy
abilities and foster their sense of being literacy producers.
Some Basics
1) Explore a Topic
Helping adult literacy students become oral historians is an exciting
project which will be beneficial to your students, you, and the local
community. It begins with a discussion of the project and an on-going
commitment of all involved to explore, capture in print, and celebrate the
uniqueness of particular lives and local history. Depending upon your
particular context, certain themes or topics will surface, for example, in
Atlantic Canada the changes in the fishery inevitably emerge.
2) Rehearse in Class
Once your students and you agree on a topic (lets use as an example
different kinds of work in the community), then it is important to prepare for
the actual interviews. Such preparation will include the following:
determination of particular people to interview; investigation through reading
and discussion of the particular jobs; generation of possible questions to ask
the interviewee; demonstration of brief note-taking strategies; utilization of
the tape recorder; and opportunities to role play the interview with peers.
We stress that classroom preparation is vitally important;
without it, these efforts will either fail or produce lackluster results. We
suggest that your students prepare to interview in teams of two. As partners
they will be able to support each other, and a more proficient reader and
writer will be able to assist one with lesser abilities. Your modelling of
note-taking, asking open-ended questions, and using the tape recorder in an
unobtrusive manner will help the students then practice among themselves. It is
better to spend too much time in such preparation than too little.
3) Interview in the
Community Once the students feel confident, they will go out
into the community equipped with a small tape recorder (this is a must), list
of possible questions, and perhaps a camera; as a team they will meet with
their interviewee at a pre-arranged time and place. (We recommend a quiet
setting on the interviewees home ground.) The interview should be an
informal conversation but should be structured around the topic at hand.
Its too easy to lose focus and ramble on to many other subjects; this can
result in a less-useful and hard-to-work-with interview. One or both of the
interviewers will take brief notes (words or phrases) which might help them
highlight important parts of the audio tape. If appropriate, and if the
interviewee agrees, photographs might be taken, for example, a boat builder
from Digby Neck next to his boat or a shopkeeper from Trail among her shelves
and counters of goods.
 |
Louise Belbin made fish on the beaches
at Grand Bank, Newfoundland. "You had to go on the beach to earn a few
dollars...That was in the depression years, and we knowed it was a depression
too." |
4) Work with the Interview Data
During this phase of the work, students practice and celebrate
their own literacies. They start by listening to their interview, absorbing the
unique voice and language of the speaker, and the pulse of the story. Students
might replay the tape two or three times before they begin to identify content
chunks. This can be done by using the counter that is a standard feature of
most recording units. Specific sentences and sections can be transcribed at the
computer or with pen and paper. Hours of tape produces hundreds of typed pages
and that project is more than many professionals can manage. That is why we
place emphasis on planning before entering the interview setting, chunking the
material, and making selections for transcribing.
Throughout this process, students will be engaged in meaningful
reading and writing. They might be exposed to new content, the particular
vocabulary of a trade or time, and the importance of voice, a sadly neglected
component of some adult literacy programs. Most importantly, oral history
provides a context to learn standard written English without diminishing the
dialect of the speaker. Students also assume the role of structural editor,
something few have ever experienced, as they make decisions about the content
to be used, and how oral language can be transposed into print for the reader.
5) Publication and Beyond
As individual stories are finalized, students share the texts.
At this stage, the classroom is again provided with more opportunities for
reading and writing. Now many publication matters arise. There are many ways to
engage students in the final proofread, organization and launch of the
publication. We recommend, whenever possible, that each student be given an
opportunity to both share a strength and apply new knowledge.
Useful References
There are various sources for practical information on gathering and using
oral histories with students of all ages. Two that we like are cited below.
Brown, Cynthia Stokes. (1988). Like it was: A complete guide
to writing oral history. New York: Teachers & Writers Collaborative.
Howarth, Ken. (1998). Oral history: A handbook. United
Kingdom: Sutton Publishing Ltd.
* About the authors
Frank teaches at the St. Cloud State University in Minnesota. Helen is a
consultant with Educational Planning and Design Associates in St. Johns,
Newfoundland. Frank and Helen have designed distance education programs for
literacy instructors and students. |